Return to buzzcut.com

This page was saved using WebZIP 7.0.3.1030 offline browser (Unregistered) on 04/01/07 5:37:59 PM.
Address: http://www.buzzcut.com/article.php?story=20041019193524726
Title: buzzcut.com - Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions  •  Size: 95045

   buzzcut logo
Advanced
Welcome to buzzcut.com
Sunday, April 01 2007 @ 10:28 PM UTC
     Sections   
Home
Areas of Interest
Game Theory
Notable Quotes
Newsletter
Games and Society
Critical Writing
Books and Articles
Critical Elements
Bibliography
General News

     Email Alerts   
Alert me to site updates--new articles, posts of notes and anything else making a trip back to buzzcut memorable.
Email:
Privacy policy: we will not share your name and email address with any 3rd party without your consent.

     What's New   
STORIES
No new stories

COMMENTS last 2 wks
No new comments

LINKS last 2 wks
No recent new links

     User Functions   
Username:

Password:

Don't have an account yet? Sign up as a New User

     Events   
There are no upcoming events

     Older Stories   
Friday 03-Mar
  • EA's "Black" opens like a film. So why doesn't it feel like one? (16)

  • Thursday 02-Mar
  • Considering Gravity (7)

  • Monday 13-Feb
  • The Medium Is Not The Message (21)

  • Thursday 19-Jan
  • All Your Readers Belong To Us (10)

  • Friday 13-Jan
  • Censorless Violence (12)

  • Tuesday 10-Jan
  • Disneyfied (Disney Fried?) (20)

  • Friday 30-Dec
  • The Escape from Xmas (14)
  • Videogames: Closing the Annoying Gap (24)

  • Tuesday 15-Nov
  • Gerbils (19)

  • Thursday 13-Oct
  • Suddenly Serious about Games (12)


  •    Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions  
     
    Tuesday, October 19 2004 @ 07:35 PM UTC
    Contributed by: David

    There’s a great scene in the class Steve Martin movie “The Jerk” where his character leaps with joy shouting, “The new phonebooks are here, the new phonebooks are here!”

    I feel a little like that since receiving my advance copy of James Newman and Iain Simons’ "Difficult Questions About Videogames"

    The book offers 969 responses from 71 contributors to 13 maddeningly direct questions about videogames. For example, the question that opens the tome is, “What is a videogame?” The answers always seem obvious until you actually try to articulate an answer.

    I haven’t yet plowed through the book in the detail it deserves. But my first pass through shows that the project lives up to its promise, colliding a wide variety of contributors offering a delicious collection of answers. Although packaged in an attractive square-bound package, the book has all the electric random energy of the blogsphere, ideas bouncing and shooting about.

    Part of my interest in this book is selfish. I am one of the 71 contributors. So, there is a certain amount of cringing that goes on when reading my responses butted up against others who have simply done of better job of nailing the answer. But I suspect that anyone will enjoy how the ideas pile on each other, how they reflect and magnify, conflict and contrast each other.

    And the responses range from the sublime to the humorously poignant. To wit:

    What is a videogame?

    “A videogame is a means by which we learn to control the 21st century. By playing, we situate and understand ourselves as citizens of hyperactive electronic space.” – Justin Hall

    Why do you play videogames?
    “To explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go where no man has gone before. I’m not kidding.” – Ernest Adams

    And along the way, by casting so many different rays at the object of inquiry, you start to feel like you have a better perspective on the subject under consideration.

    The contributors range from gamers and academics to game developers and wags. I’m happy to see such familiar faces as Bogost, Consalvo, Falstein, Frasca, Juul and Spector on the contributor’s list as well as a bunch of new names As you would expect, reading through the book, you find yourself mentally scoring the answers, wishing you could ask for a rebuttal or clarification and wondering what someone whose name is missing from the lit of contributors might have said.

    Public Beta has promised that this is simply a version 1 of an ongoing project. Add I hope that’s the case. I’m ready to buy version 2, just to see what other people have to say about the same topic. In fact, my only criticism at this point is one unavoidable with a project such as this—give me more!

    The book should be available for order in the coming weeks on the Public Beta site. For those fortunate enough to live near their home base in the U.K., Public Beta is sponsoring a series of public events. Check their Website for book and event information.






     
             


    Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions | 26 comments | Create New Account
    The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
    Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions
    Authored by: Noogle on Wednesday, October 20 2004 @ 12:44 PM UTC
    Okay, no contact details on the site, no price on the book, no obvious means to order...

    Is this perhaps a Slashdot project?

    I'd love to read this, but it appears to be unattainable. Maybe someone should email them...

    ---
    nag.blog
    (http://www.nag.co.za/blog)

    Binge & Purge - Fueling the Game Rant Engine
    (http://www.nag.co.za/bnp/)
    [ Reply to This ]
  • Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions - Authored by: iainsimons on Wednesday, October 20 2004 @ 04:20 PM UTC
  • Smart Remarks on Difficult Questions - Authored by: Haarball on Sunday, November 14 2004 @ 11:46 PM UTC
  •      What's Related   
  • "Difficult Questions Ab...
  • Public Beta site
  • More by David
  • More from Books and Articles

  •      Story Options   
  • Mail Story to a Friend
  • Printable Story Format


  •  : site-index : Copyright © 2007 buzzcut.com
     All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
    Powered By Geeklog 
    Assimilated by Aeonserv 
    Created this page in 0.46 seconds